I’m minorly convinced that The Good Place and Brooklyn Nine-Nine are somehow set in the same universe.
Which means either it’s a very insane coincidence, or Captain Holt just happens to be married to a immortal demon judge from Hell. No biggie.
Some headcanons, because I’m getting quite smitten with this idea and it seems a lot of other folks are, too.
1) Gina would end up in The Bad Place. Not to punish her. No, The Bad Place is her Good Place. She’s happiest there, and would probably rule it within a day of arriving. The demons are all impressed by her ability to torture without even trying. Kinda terrified, too.
2) Rosa and Eleanor would immediately go on a date. Just, immediate attraction. Slo-mo style intense.
3) Tahani and Captain Holt would have a wonderful time being cultured together. Amy, too. And Chidi. They’d definitely start a book club.
4) Meanwhile, Jake and Jason would do as much impossibly stupid shit as they can because, you know, unable to die or experience pain (unless they’re in a place specifically meant to do so). Boyle would join in, reservedly at first but then he’d be the wildest one of all. He’d have fun.
5) Terry and Chidi would absolutely bond over shared anxiety. They exchange notes on how Best to Deal. Terry essentially adopts him; dude is such a Mom friend.